Hydrotherapy in a Treadmill or Pool

We get asked quite a lot why we have a hydrotherapy pool but don’t have a treadmill at our centre and there are a few simple reasons but as clients and veterinarians become more aware of underwater treadmills we thought it would be a good idea to discuss the benefits of both so that you can come to your own conclusions about what might be best for your dog.

The rise in popularity of treadmill appears to be primarily fed by two areas:

  • An increase in the amount of scientific research being undertaken in them
  • An increase in their availability for vets and therapists due to the smaller size they occupy

However, before diving into some more analysis there’s a couple of things we think you should know:


How therapists see hydrotherapy

A good therapist will understand the biomechanics of your dog. They will know that your dog is designed to move forwards not backwards, that movement is driven by a combination of muscle power and the proprioceptive system (both in a conscious and unconscious state). And, they will understand that it is their role in rehabilitation to provide movement enriching activity in an aquatic environment.

Historically, most people will think of hydrotherapy in two forms – swimming in a pool and walking in a treadmill. Over the last decade the understanding and scientific research in hydrotherapy has advanced considerably and this is no longer the way to think of hydrotherapy. We can increase the water depth to swim a dog in an underwater treadmill and we can use pods to walk a dog in a hydrotherapy pool. So this brings us back to “it’s a facility to aid movement”

Primarily a hydrotherapist uses their tools to:

  • Improve your dogs engagement with their natural balance and stance
  • Shape movement appropriately
  • Align your dog properly
  • Undertake dynamic exercise
  • Undertake static exercises

An Underwater Treadmill

Provides…

  • Ability to quickly control water height
  • The ability to walk and swim dogs
  • Ability to undertake dynamic & static handling
  • Compact space compatible treatment
  • The need for just one therapist

Can be limited in…

  • Therapists access to all areas of the dog
  • Ability to control humidity
  • Ability to control overstretch of the spine
  • The ability to vary rehabilitation techniques

A Hydrotherapy Pool

Provides…

  • A therapist with 360 degree control
  • Better control of humidity and temperature
  • Proprioceptively rich therapies
  • Ability to undertake dynamic & static handling
  • The ability to walk and swim dogs

Can be limited in…

  • Supporting nervous dogs
  • Provision for compact treatment centres
  • Single therapist treatment of paralysis conditions

How do you make the right choice

As you can see from above, both formats provide the ability to undertake extensive portfolios of dynamic and static handling techniques however ultimately the decision should come down to the Behaviour and Breed Standards of your animal – not the marketing ploys of hydrotherapy businesses.

So, in our opinion, choose a hydrotherapy centre with…

A Hydrotherapy Pool

If your dog:

  • Is a brachycephalic breed due to the humidity risks of a treadmill
  • Is nervous of enclosed environments due to the nature of a treadmill
  • Is an amputee as a dog losing balance in a treadmill could be catastrophic
  • Is a large breed that simple won’t comfortably fit in anything other than a pool

An Underwater Treadmill

If your dog:

  • Is nervous of large open environments due to the nature of a hydrotherapy pool
  • Is nervous of water as treadmills can be filled slowly
  • Has significant access issues due to the ability to enter and exit easily* or where second therapists are unavailable

This is of course not an exhaustive list that you as the owner or veterinary care professional might think of but these, in our opinion, are the primary reasons. Otherwise, it comes down to what therapist do you trust and how well do they know their equipment to help your dog.

*We caveat this point with a comment that you must make sure the UWTM has two doors, so that it doesn’t have to turn 180 degrees inside the treadmill to exit


The Canine Fitness Centre Facilities

We want to be clear that this is not a marketing piece around why we have a pool and why it could be seen as superior compared to an underwater treadmill. Hopefully this article has been informative to help you make the right decision for your dog.

At the Canine Fitness Centre we have chosen to have an 18ft by 9ft heated hydrotherapy pool because:

  • Our therapists can have a 360 degree view of your animal swimming, walking and standing
  • Dogs do not overstretch their necks and spine when looking at their owners due to the owners positioning
  • We have a much greater level of ‘up-time’ where the pool is not reliant on underwater mechanics
  • Our skilled therapists can supercharge proprioceptive treatments by combining aquatic walking & swimming
  • We can control the level of humidity in the room particularly in summer months
  • We focus on treating the dog and it’s needs rather than the capabilities and space of our equipment
  • We have access to multiple therapists so can provide support to dogs with access needs
  • Hydrotherapy pools are much better for therapist wellbeing due to the stances required in an UWTM

We will never accept a dog that we believe demonstrates behaviours that are only suitable for an underwater treadmill and will always refer you to one of our partner sites who have this facility if it will be the best thing for your dog.


Think this is biased? Watch the webinar and analysis from Barbara Houlding, a leading Hydrotherapist and Physiotherapist in the field. Barbara is a course leader for at K9HS and discusses many of the same views outlined above in her online webinar found here.